Tarte tubing mascara dupes, ranked by ingredient list and price

How tarte tubing wears: One blogger praises it for lengthening and lifting with no flaking, but another tester found it too natural for how little it held a curl. Both say it comes off with warm water only.

1. 

   1. Milani Highly Rated Lash Extensions Lengthening Tubing Mascara

   9 of tarte XL's first 9 · shares 21 · same tube polymer · $13.97 for 10.4 mL ($1.34/mL)

   How it wears: A BuzzFeed writer says it made her short, pale lashes look much longer, did not flake, and came off in one swipe with a warm, wet paper towel. A review summary says the length looks natural, but it can flake or clump if applied heavily.

   Best for the closest match to tarte. Its first 9 ingredients are the same 9 that start tarte's XL list, led by the same tube-forming polymer. It shares 21 of the XL's 27 ingredients, including niacinamide.

   Trade-off: It is close, not a copy. It adds laureth-50, jojoba esters and sunflower wax, and it leaves out the XL's biotin, peptide and PVP.

   Buy on Amazon $13.97
2. 

   2. essence Lash Without Limits Extreme Lengthening & Volume Tubing Mascara

   4 of tarte XL's first 9 · shares 11 · same tube polymer · $4.97 for 13 mL ($0.38/mL)

   How it wears: A February 2026 Lift Bake Love tester calls it her lightest, most natural-looking pick, with well-separated lashes. Mascaras Insider warns it takes patience to remove because the formula sets firmly.

   Best for the lowest price. It uses the same tube-forming polymer as tarte, second on the list, in the biggest tube here (13 mL).

   Trade-off: The rest of the formula is different (no glycerin, alcohol or shea near the top), and testers say it takes patience to remove.

   Buy on Amazon $4.97
3. 

   3. Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky Tubes Tubing Mascara

   2 of tarte XL's first 9 · shares 7 · different polymers · $9.99 for 6.8 mL ($1.47/mL)

   How it wears: Marie Claire UK's beauty director (April 2026) says it separates lashes, never sets stiff, lasts all day and comes off with warm water. She needed a couple of extra coats for lift, and the black is a little soft.

   Best for lashes that never feel stiff. It is a true tubing mascara that comes off with warm water, and a Marie Claire UK editor says it never sets stiff. Its Amazon title says shea butter, but Maybelline's own ingredient list has none.

   Trade-off: It is built on different polymers, so it is not a formula match. The tube is the smallest here (6.8 mL), and the black is a little soft.

   Buy on Amazon $9.99
4. 

   4. L'Oreal Paris Double Extend Beauty Tubes Tubing Mascara

   2 of tarte XL's first 9 · shares 4 · different polymers · $7.07 for 9.8 mL ($0.72/mL)

   How it wears: Mascaras Insider calls the two-step system a length builder. A 2009 review on Musings of a Muse says the white base coat looks clumpy at first, but the result is long lashes with no flaking, and it comes off easily with warm water.

   Best for the most length. A white base coat goes on first, then a black tubing top coat. Reviewers call it a length builder.

   Trade-off: It is a different system: two steps, different polymers, and both coats list parabens.

   Buy on Amazon $7.07

Amazon prices checked Nov 2, 2026. Milani, L'Oreal and Maybelline sizes are printed in fl oz; we converted them to mL.

• The tubes: water, then acrylates/ethylhexyl acrylate copolymer, the polymer that wraps each lash. tarte says it "removes in tubes with warm water, no rubbing or scrubbing."
• The body: glyceryl stearate, alcohol, glycerin, carnauba wax, stearic acid and VP/eicosene copolymer. Shea butter and castor oil come next.
• The XL version: the same start, plus dimethicone, biotin, a peptide (biotinoyl tripeptide-1), niacinamide and panthenol. 27 ingredients vs 18.
• Wear claim: 24-hour, flake-free and smudge-proof, per tarte. Its FAQ says it is not waterproof.

What is the best dupe for Tarte tubing mascara?

Milani Highly Rated Tubing Mascara. Its first 9 ingredients match the first 9 of tarte's XL tubing formula, and it shares 21 of the XL's 27. It costs $13.97 for 10.4 mL ($1.34/mL) vs $28.00 for 8 mL ($3.50/mL).

Is essence Lash Without Limits a good tarte tubing dupe?

For price, yes: $4.97 for 13 mL ($0.38/mL), with the same tube-forming polymer. The rest of its list is different, and testers say it is slow to remove.

Is Maybelline Sky Tubes the same as tarte tubing?

No. Both are tubing mascaras that come off with warm water, but Maybelline uses different polymers. Pick it for soft, flexible lashes, not as a formula match.

1. Ingredient lists: each brand's own product page (tartecosmetics.com, milanicosmetics.com, lorealparisusa.com, maybelline.com), and SkinSort for essence (its US site does not list the black shade), read November 1, 2026.
2. Sizes: as printed by the brand; Milani from its Target listing (0.35 fl oz) and L'Oreal from a Vitacost listing (0.33 fl oz), because neither brand page prints a size. fl oz converted to mL (1 fl oz = 29.57 mL).
3. Amazon prices, sellers and listings: Amazon product data, refreshed every night.
4. How each one wears, from reviews: Why I Finally Gave Tubing Mascara a Second Chance (50 Is Not Old); Best Tubing Mascara for Lashes that Can't Hold a Curl (Lift Bake Love, Feb 2026); tarte tartelette XL tubing mascara (brand page, consumer-test claims); 10 Best Tubing Mascaras Drugstore Favorites in 2026 (Mascaras Insider); Milani tubing mascara review (BuzzFeed); Milani tubing mascara review summary (ShopSavvy); L'Oreal Double Extend Mascara Review (Musings of a Muse, Feb 2009); Maybelline's First Tubing Mascara Has Landed (Marie Claire UK, 27 Apr 2026).