What is the best CeraVe Acne Foaming Cream Cleanser dupe?

PanOxyl Acne Foaming Wash ($9.89) discloses a HIGHER 10% benzoyl peroxide on its own FDA Drug Facts panel, versus CeraVe's disclosed 4% — the same active, at a nominally stronger dose, in the same foaming wash-off format, for less money.

Is PanOxyl 10% too strong to replace CeraVe 4%?

It can be, for reactive or dry skin. 10% benzoyl peroxide is more likely to dry out or irritate than 4%, and PanOxyl's formula has no ceramides or niacinamide the way CeraVe's does. Introduce it gradually and pair with a moisturizer if you switch.

Why is CeraVe's benzoyl peroxide cleanser more expensive than PanOxyl?

CeraVe builds its 4% benzoyl peroxide into a three-ceramide (NP, AP, EOP) plus niacinamide barrier-support base — a real formulation difference dermatologists cite for acne-prone skin that's also reactive. PanOxyl is a simpler, higher-dose surfactant system without that supporting cast.

Dupe report Nº 034 / Benzoyl peroxide foaming washes

CeraVe Acne Foaming Cream Cleanser dupes, ranked by formula match

The verdict

PanOxyl Acne Foaming Wash is the cheaper bottle at $9.89 vs $13.62, with 10% benzoyl peroxide vs CeraVe's 4%. It is stronger and more drying. It is also the bigger bottle (163 mL against 148 mL), so it costs less per mL too.

Buy PanOxyl Acne Foaming Wash — $9.89 Buy the original — $13.62

Side by side: the original and our pick
Measure	CeraVethe original	PanOxylour pick
Benzoyl Peroxide	4%	10%
Ingredients in common	28 on the label	7 of the 28
Size	148 mL	163 mL
Price	$13.62	$9.89
Price per mL	$0.092	$0.061

Amazon prices checked Nov 3, 2026. Percentages are the ones each brand prints. How we check ↓

This is not a same-strength dupe, and we want to say that upfront: PanOxyl's Acne Foaming Wash discloses a HIGHER benzoyl peroxide concentration (10%) than CeraVe's Acne Foaming Cream Cleanser (4%) — both numbers are the FDA OTC active percentage printed on each product's own Drug Facts panel. PanOxyl is not a diluted copy; it is the nominally stronger acne wash, in the identical foaming, wash-off format, for less money per bottle and per gram of active. The formulas differ beyond the dose, too: CeraVe builds its cleanser on a three-ceramide (NP, AP, EOP) plus niacinamide barrier-support base that PanOxyl's simpler surfactant system does not replicate at all — a real reason dermatologists often recommend CeraVe for acne-prone skin that is also barrier-compromised or reactive. 10% benzoyl peroxide is also just more likely to dry out or irritate sensitive skin than 4%, so 'stronger' is not automatically 'better' here. If you want the gentler, barrier-supporting formula at a lower, FDA-standard acne dose, CeraVe earns its modest premium. If you specifically want the maximum OTC benzoyl peroxide strength in the same wash-off format for less money, PanOxyl is the honest, cheaper, and technically stronger pick — just introduce it gradually if your skin is reactive.

4 % ✓ original Benzoyl Peroxide

$9.89 vs $13.62 original PanOxyl

Best available match: 68% base-formula score — the highest we measured across the candidates. Scores reflect formula proximity — read the actives column for the clinical story. How we score ↓

The winner

PanOxyl Acne Foaming Wash with 10% Benzoyl Peroxide - 5.5 oz

Discloses a HIGHER 10% benzoyl peroxide on its own FDA Drug Facts panel, versus the original's disclosed 4%, in the identical foaming wash-off format. 4.5-star average across 706 Amazon ratings, at $9.89 versus $13.62. Honest caveat: no ceramides or niacinamide, and the higher dose is more likely to dry out or irritate reactive skin.

Buy on Amazon $9.89 Breakdown ↓

Updated October 31, 2026

PanOxyl discloses a HIGHER 10% benzoyl peroxide in the same foaming-wash format, for less.

02 / The scoreboard

2 formulas, one number that matters

Read the actives column first — it is the apples-to-apples comparison. $ per gram of active is what the working ingredients cost you; the base-formula score is supporting evidence, not the verdict.

Product	Actives vs original	$ / g of active	Price	Base formula	Verdict
CeraVe Acne Foaming Cream Cleanser	Benzoyl peroxide 4.0% (FDA OTC Drug Facts-verified active)	$2.30	$13.62 148 mL · Amazon	100% the reference	The original
Partial overlap missing actives — different formula wearing the keywords
PanOxyl Acne Foaming Wash with 10% Benzoyl Peroxide - 5.5 oz	Benzoyl peroxide 10.0% (FDA OTC Drug Facts-verified active)	$0.61	$9.89 163 mL · Amazon	68% highest measured	The winner Amazon →

✓ same % as original ≠ different % ? in formula, % undisclosed — not in formula

03 / The original

Why the original is the original

CeraVe's Acne Foaming Cream Cleanser leads with 4% benzoyl peroxide — the FDA OTC active ingredient, disclosed on the Drug Facts panel — built into CeraVe's signature three-ceramide (NP, AP, EOP) barrier base with niacinamide and hyaluronic acid. It is a real reason dermatologists often recommend this specific cleanser for acne-prone skin that is also reactive or barrier-compromised.

PanOxyl's Acne Foaming Wash discloses a HIGHER 10% benzoyl peroxide — both numbers pulled verbatim from each product's own FDA Drug Facts panel — in the identical foaming, wash-off format. PanOxyl is not a diluted copy; it is the nominally stronger acne wash, for less money per bottle and per gram of active. What it does not replicate is CeraVe's ceramide-and-niacinamide barrier base — PanOxyl's formula is a simpler surfactant system with no ceramides at all.

10% benzoyl peroxide is also just more likely to dry out or irritate sensitive skin than 4%, so "stronger" is not automatically "better" here. If you want the gentler, barrier-supporting formula at a lower, dermatologist-favored acne dose, CeraVe earns its modest premium. If you specifically want the maximum OTC strength in the same wash-off format for less money, PanOxyl is the honest, cheaper, and technically stronger pick — just introduce it gradually if your skin is reactive.

04 / The candidates

Every candidate, examined

01 / PanOxyl

The winner

PanOxyl Acne Foaming Wash with 10% Benzoyl Peroxide - 5.5 oz bottle

$0.61 per g of active

$9.89 retail · 163 mL

68% base formula · highest of 6

PanOxyl Acne Foaming Wash with 10% Benzoyl Peroxide - 5.5 oz

Shared formula DNA 6 of 28 original ingredients present

Benzoyl Peroxide Water Glycerin Propylene Glycol Cocamidopropyl Hydroxysultaine Sodium C14-16 Olefin Sulfonate Xanthan Gum Potassium Hydroxide Ceramide Np Ceramide Ap Ceramide Eop Carbomer Niacinamide Glycolic Acid Sodium Chloride Sodium Citrate Sodium Hyaluronate Sodium Lauroyl Lactylate Sodium Hydroxide Cholesterol Phenoxyethanol Propanediol Citric Acid Tetrasodium Edta Diethylhexyl Sodium Sulfosuccinate Phytosphingosine Ethylhexylglycerin Benzoic Acid

shared with original not shared rare marker — weighs more in the score

What matches: Discloses a HIGHER 10% benzoyl peroxide on its own FDA Drug Facts panel, versus CeraVe's disclosed 4% — the same FDA OTC active, at a nominally stronger dose, in the identical foaming wash-off format.
What differs: No ceramides and no niacinamide — PanOxyl's formula is a simpler surfactant system. CeraVe's three-ceramide (NP, AP, EOP) plus niacinamide base is a real reason dermatologists favor it for reactive or barrier-compromised acne-prone skin. 10% is also more likely to dry out or irritate than 4%.
Who it's for: The winner if you want the maximum OTC benzoyl peroxide strength in the same wash-off format for less money — $9.89 versus $13.62, 4.5 stars across 706 ratings. Introduce it gradually if your skin is reactive.

Ships in: Packaging not verified No brand or retailer statement on the bottle — we won’t guess.
pH: pH not published L-ascorbic acid needs pH below 3.5 to absorb
Data source: Benzoyl peroxide 10.0% (FDA OTC Drug Facts-verified active) Benzoyl peroxide 10.0% disclosed as the FDA OTC active ingredient on the Drug Facts panel / product name; INCI verified verbatim (Ulta product page). 5.5 oz (163 mL) size from the Amazon listing (2026-10-30); the price is read from Amazon every day.

$9.89 for 163 mL → $0.61 per gram of active — 3.8× cheaper per active gram than the original's $2.30.

Buy on Amazon $9.89

05 / Methodology

How we verified this

Verified July 29, 2026

Every formula on this page was tokenized — split into its individual INCI ingredients — and matched against the EU CosIng ingredient database, so "Aqua," "Water," and "Eau" all resolve to the same ingredient.

The base-formula match score works like this: sharing a rare ingredient counts far more than sharing a common one. Almost every serum contains water and glycerin — that proves nothing. Almost nothing contains Ethoxydiglycol or Laureth-23, so when a candidate shares those with the original, it says something real about how the formula was built. (For the statisticians: it is an IDF-weighted Jaccard similarity over the normalized ingredient lists.)

Scores are computed, not opinions. The verdict tags are our editorial read of the actives, the scores, and the prices — and the methodology stays public so you can disagree with us precisely.

Where the ingredient lists come from

Benzoyl peroxide 4.0% (FDA OTC Drug Facts-verified active)
Benzoyl peroxide 10.0% (FDA OTC Drug Facts-verified active)

Sources for this report

FDA OTC Drug Facts panels — benzoyl peroxide active percentages
INCIDecoder / Ulta product pages — INCI verified verbatim
Amazon Creators PA-API — ASIN/price/rating verification
Verified Beauty Data's own product records

06 / Questions

Frequently asked

What is the best CeraVe Acne Foaming Cream Cleanser dupe?: PanOxyl Acne Foaming Wash ($9.89) discloses a HIGHER 10% benzoyl peroxide on its own FDA Drug Facts panel, versus CeraVe's disclosed 4% — the same active, at a nominally stronger dose, in the same foaming wash-off format, for less money.
Is PanOxyl 10% too strong to replace CeraVe 4%?: It can be, for reactive or dry skin. 10% benzoyl peroxide is more likely to dry out or irritate than 4%, and PanOxyl's formula has no ceramides or niacinamide the way CeraVe's does. Introduce it gradually and pair with a moisturizer if you switch.
Why is CeraVe's benzoyl peroxide cleanser more expensive than PanOxyl?: CeraVe builds its 4% benzoyl peroxide into a three-ceramide (NP, AP, EOP) plus niacinamide barrier-support base — a real formulation difference dermatologists cite for acne-prone skin that's also reactive. PanOxyl is a simpler, higher-dose surfactant system without that supporting cast.